All Blacks Squad Winners and Losers: Does Scott Robertson’s Latest Selection Hint at Desperation?
Scott Robertson’s selection of the 36-man squad for the All Blacks’ upcoming end-of-year tour has stirred up a wave of speculation.
After a challenging Rugby Championship season, many expected the coach to make bold moves in preparation for the 2027 World Cup. However, the decision to retain certain veteran players while giving limited chances to rising talents suggests a strategy focused on immediate results, raising questions about the long-term direction of the team.
The inclusion of veterans Sam Cane and TJ Perenara has puzzled many fans. Both players, pillars of the team for years, are set to retire from Test rugby at the end of the year.
While their experience is undeniable, their selection could indicate a short-term focus by Robertson. Some are wondering if these choices prioritize a final push for success in upcoming matches against England, Ireland, and France, over the need to develop new talent. Cane and Perenara’s presence risks stalling the All Blacks' transformation for the next World Cup cycle.
One of the more promising names on the list is Cam Roigard, who returned to the squad after a long injury hiatus. Roigard’s resurgence comes after scoring two tries in a recent NPC match, reminding everyone of his potential. Although still relatively untested on the international stage, his inclusion suggests that Robertson sees him as a future cornerstone of the team. However, the question remains: how much game time will he get, especially with Perenara also in the mix? Roigard’s performance on this tour could significantly impact his role in the All Blacks’ future plans.
Another contentious aspect of the selection is the inclusion of Stephen Perofeta and Ruben Love, both of whom have faced injury setbacks and have limited recent playtime. With Beauden Barrett and Damian McKenzie still commanding the number 10 jersey, many wonder if it was the right time to bring these young talents into the spotlight. While they may not see much action against the powerhouse teams like England and Ireland, the matches against Japan and Italy could provide them with the experience they need to step up in the future.
Despite a below-average season with the Crusaders, David Havili has managed to retain his spot. Many fans and analysts are baffled by this decision, as Havili has struggled to replicate his Super Rugby form at the Test level. At 29, time is running out for him to establish himself as a regular starter for the All Blacks, making this tour a critical moment in his career.
With younger, more in-form players waiting in the wings, Havili will need to prove that Robertson’s loyalty is justified.
Wingers Sevu Reece and Mark Tele’a are two players who need a standout performance during this tour. Both have had disappointing international seasons and must prove they deserve to stay in the squad moving forward. New Zealand never lacks quality in the back three, and if these two fail to deliver, there are plenty of young talents ready to step up.
For Reece, in particular, this tour could determine whether he continues to have a future with the national team.
One of the biggest shocks of the selection was the exclusion of Finlay Christie. Despite his strong performances in the NPC, he has not been given a recall. This move indicates that Christie is now far down the pecking order, with the likes of Roigard and Ratima being favored.
Christie's omission speaks volumes about Robertson's approach, showing a clear focus on players who fit his vision for the future, even if that means sidelining consistent performers.
As the All Blacks prepare for their northern tour, the squad’s balance between veterans and emerging talent has sparked debate. Is Robertson being too conservative by relying on experienced players who won’t be around for the next World Cup, or is this exactly the kind of stability the All Blacks need right now? With key matches against top-tier European teams on the horizon, Robertson’s choices will soon be put to the test.
What do you think of the All Blacks’ selections? Are they setting up for success, or is Robertson missing an opportunity to prepare the team for the future? Share your thoughts!
